How secondary legislation works
Secondary legislation is law made by ministers under powers that an Act of Parliament has granted them, most commonly in the form of statutory instruments. It vastly outnumbers primary legislation: Parliament passes a few dozen Acts in a typical year, while ministers make well over a thousand statutory instruments. Parliament checks them through two main procedures, negative and affirmative, but cannot normally amend them: each instrument is accepted or rejected whole.
Where the power comes from
Every statutory instrument rests on a parent Act. The Act sets out what ministers may do by regulation and which scrutiny procedure applies, and those choices are themselves fought over during the bill’s passage: a broadly drawn regulation-making power is often more consequential than anything else in the bill, because it determines how much law can later be made without a bill at all.
The negative procedure
Most instruments follow the negative procedure. The instrument is laid before Parliament and becomes, or remains, law unless either House annuls it within forty days, by a motion known as a prayer. In practice annulment is vanishingly rare: most negative instruments pass into law without ever being debated. For anyone affected by them, the practical scrutiny window is those forty days, and it is easy to miss.
The affirmative procedure
Instruments the parent Act deems more significant follow the affirmative procedure: they cannot take effect, or cannot remain in effect, unless both Houses actively approve them. In the Commons the debate usually happens in a delegated legislation committee before a formal approval vote in the House. An urgent variant lets an instrument be made and take effect immediately, subject to approval within a set period afterwards.
The limits of scrutiny
Two features define scrutiny of secondary legislation. First, instruments cannot normally be amended: each House takes or leaves the text as laid, which blunts the incentive to engage with the detail. Second, rejection is extraordinarily rare. The Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments checks drafting and whether an instrument is within the parent Act’s powers, and the Lords has its own scrutiny committees, but the Lords has voted down statutory instruments only a handful of times since the Second World War.
The practical lesson for anyone tracking policy: by the time an instrument is laid, the decisions have been made. The time to influence secondary legislation is during the consultation that precedes it, and earlier still, when the parent Act’s powers are being written.
Related guides
Emily tracks every bill through these stages for her clients: alerts when one moves, briefings on what it means, and who to talk to about it.
Get Emily on your issues